Files
hermes-agent/tui_gateway/methods_bot_relay.py
teknium1 c55a6e3d9f feat(desktop): identity-attribution traces for multi-connection bot rosters
Change-only desktop.log / agent.log lines that name which writer moved a
bot identity when two connections share a profile name:

- [gateway-route] per (connection, profile): via=primary|secondary and the
  window primary; `active` on every active-scope change (key, socket
  connection, profile) and `published` on every published-connection
  change, so a socket/label disagreement shows up side by side.
- [bot-roster] each Bots-pane snapshot: the install that ANSWERED
  profiles.list vs the install expected for activeConnectionId;
  MISROUTED when they differ.
- [bot-relay] rows per connection with the answering install; MISROUTED
  when two connections answer from the same install.
- [bot-meta] every $botMeta title change per scoped key.
- backend: bot_relay.roster.sync and ui_meta['hermes-bots'].title writes.

profiles.list now echoes install_id (same value as /api/status) so a
client can prove which machine answered a routed list. Additive field;
older clients ignore it. Plugins reach the tracer through
host.traceIdentityChange?.() so wholesale SDK mocks stay valid.
2026-10-02 21:11:01 -07:00

276 lines
16 KiB
Python

"""Bot-relay JSON-RPC handlers — the gateway side of cross-connection A2A. Connections ARE the
peer set: the Desktop owns every gateway socket and relays between them via four doors on EACH
gateway: ``roster.sync`` (push OTHER connections' agents so ``message_agent`` resolves them),
``outbox.drain`` (collect envelopes queued here for other connections), ``deliver`` (one-turn Bot
Chat delivery on the TARGET gateway, returns the reply), ``reply`` (write the reply/error back on
the SENDER gateway for its waiter). Plumbing: ``tools/bot_relay.py``; handlers are rebound onto
server.py's globals (method_ctx.py) and reference ``_ok``/``_err`` bare."""
import contextlib
import logging
import os
import subprocess
from pathlib import Path
# Defined beside the sender-side waiter budget so the two Python sides cannot drift (#93911).
from tools.bot_failure_reasons import delivery_failure_reason
from tools.bot_relay import TURN_ATTEMPT_TIMEOUT_SECONDS
from .method_ctx import HandlerRegistry
_registry = HandlerRegistry()
method = _registry.method
def _relay_root() -> Path:
"""Install root shared by every profile (relay state is install-wide). Same formula as the
writers (``tools/bot_relay``, ``tools/bot_mode_dm``): both ends of the mailbox must agree for
every HERMES_HOME, including non-``profiles/`` subdirs of ``~/.hermes``."""
from tools.bot_mode_probe import _default_home, _hermes_root
return _hermes_root(Path(_default_home()))
def _run_delivery(profile: str, tmp: str, env: dict | None = None, *,
timeout: float = TURN_ATTEMPT_TIMEOUT_SECONDS) -> subprocess.CompletedProcess:
"""One relayed turn; the cap bounds the TURN, not the child (#114980). ``-Q`` prints its answer
only after the one-shot exit linger (a teammate's reply during it may become that answer), so a
child that exits under the cap is booked from its streams as before; one still lingering at the
cap is booked from its turn report — its answer and outcome, never a timeout — and left to finish
the linger that protects its own handoff. Only a turn that never ends is a timeout."""
from hermes_cli.quiet_single_query import run_reported_turn
from tools.bot_relay import local_delivery_command
report = f"{tmp}.turn.json"
try:
# The relay pins UTF-8 on every platform (#93590): its child is the bootstrapped hermes_cli
# and its answer is relayed verbatim, unlike the cron lane's locale-decoded tails.
return run_reported_turn(
local_delivery_command(profile, tmp), env=os.environ if env is None else env,
report_path=report, timeout=timeout, exit_grace=None, encoding="utf-8")
finally:
with contextlib.suppress(OSError):
os.unlink(report)
@method("bot_relay.roster.sync")
def _(rid, params: dict, _root=_relay_root) -> dict:
"""Replace this gateway's view of agents on OTHER connections → ``{count}`` accepted rows
(``agents`` rows ``{profile, handle, connection_id, ...}``; invalid rows are dropped).
A roster that changes is logged with its rows: a peer connection listed with this machine's
own profiles, or two publishers alternating, shows up as a flapping line (the pushing window
is in the Desktop's desktop.log ``[bot-relay win=…]`` lines at the same time)."""
try:
from tools.bot_relay import read_remote_roster, write_remote_roster
def trace() -> str:
rows = read_remote_roster(_root())
return f"n={len(rows)} [" + " ".join(
f"{r.get('connection_id')}/{r.get('profile')}={r.get('title')!r}" for r in rows) + "]"
before = trace()
count = write_remote_roster(_root(), params.get("agents"))
after = trace()
if after != before:
logging.getLogger(__name__).info("bot_relay roster changed: %s -> %s", before, after)
return _ok(rid, {"count": count})
except Exception as e:
return _err(rid, 5090, str(e))
@method("bot_relay.outbox.drain")
def _(rid, params: dict, _root=_relay_root) -> dict:
"""Claim every pending cross-connection envelope queued here → ``{envelopes}``; claimed
envelopes move to ``claimed/`` atomically so concurrent drains can't double-deliver."""
try:
from tools.bot_relay import claim_pending_envelopes
return _ok(rid, {"envelopes": claim_pending_envelopes(_root())})
except Exception as e:
return _err(rid, 5091, str(e))
@method("bot_relay.deliver")
def _(rid, params: dict, _root=_relay_root, _run=_run_delivery,
_failure_reason=delivery_failure_reason) -> dict:
"""Deliver a relayed DM (``profile``, attribution-prefixed ``message``) into a Bot Chat ON THIS
GATEWAY via the one-turn ``hermes -p <profile> chat -c "Bot Chat"`` transport local DMs use →
``{reply}``. Blocking by design (Desktop relay worker; the RPC pool keeps it off the reader)."""
import tempfile
profile = str(params.get("profile") or "").strip()
message = str(params.get("message") or "").strip()
if not profile or not message:
return _err(rid, 4090, "profile and message required")
try:
from tools.bot_mode_dm import MESSAGE_MAX_CHARS
from tools.bot_relay import acquire_turn_lock
if len(message) > MESSAGE_MAX_CHARS + 200: # + attribution headroom
return _err(rid, 4091, "message too long")
root = _root()
from tools.bot_mode_probe import _roster
known = {name for name, _ in _roster(root)}
resolved = "default" if profile.lower() == "hermes" else profile
if resolved not in known:
return _err(rid, 4092, f"no profile '{profile}' on this gateway")
# The sender stamped itself with its bare @handle; a relayed "@hermes" is ANOTHER machine's
# default, so re-stamp it with the form this gateway can reply to (#103731).
from tools.bot_mode_probe import local_taken_forms
from tools.bot_relay import qualify_sender_stamp, read_remote_roster
message = qualify_sender_stamp(message, params.get("from_handle"), params.get("from_connection"),
read_remote_roster(root), local_taken_forms(root))
# When THIS gateway already hosts the target's Bot Chat live, the subprocess transport is
# fenced out by the single-owner lease and the payload dropped (#100523). See below.
from tools.bot_mode_probe import BOT_CHAT_TITLE
live_home = _profile_home(resolved)
want_home = str(live_home) if live_home is not None else None
live_sid = next((
live_sid for live_sid, record in list(_sessions.items())
if isinstance(record, dict) and (record.get("profile_home") or None) == want_home
and _session_live_title(
record, _session_lookup_key(record, fallback=live_sid)) == BOT_CHAT_TITLE), "")
# The sender fields are whatever the relaying client says. The author labels memory only and grants nothing.
from tools.bot_relay import (
DeliveryAuthor, delivery_env, delivery_turn_author, relaying_principal_author)
from tui_gateway.methods_browser_control import _is_authenticated_identity, _principal_digest
sender_fields = ("from_profile", "from_handle", "from_connection")
identity = getattr(current_transport(), "auth_identity", None)
if _is_authenticated_identity(identity):
# A logged-in client's sender fields are NOT trusted — but the delivery is not refused
# either: the Desktop is itself a logged-in client on every gateway that requires sign-in
# (it mints a ws-ticket carrying the signed-in {user_id, provider} —
# hermes_cli/dashboard_auth/routes.py), so refusing took cross-connection relay offline
# for exactly the auth-gated gateways it serves; only ``?internal=`` callers are
# identity-exempt and the Desktop cannot present one. Nor is the author dropped: an
# unattributed turn is the HUMAN's to the recipient's memory (Honcho routes it into the
# human session and allows conclusion / profile / mirror writes), so a bot DM must stay
# bot-authored. The author is derived from the caller's minted identity instead — stable,
# unspoofable, and ``is_bot`` — whether or not the client named a sender. The human-facing
# "Message from 🤖 …" signature stays in the text the sender composed.
author = relaying_principal_author(_principal_digest(identity))
else:
author = delivery_turn_author(*(params.get(k) for k in sender_fields))
# This process's _sessions is not the ownership authority: the Desktop pools one backend per
# (connection, profile) and an SSH source runs one remote dashboard per profile, so the
# target's Bot Chat can be live in a sibling process on this host while the relay RPC lands
# here. The subprocess transport would then be refused SESSION_NOT_OWNED by that owner's
# lease (#113753). Hand the DM to the live owner — this process or a sibling — through the
# same mailbox local DMs use (tools/bot_mode_dm.py::_run_delivery); its poller admits it at
# the next idle boundary and settles a receipt carrying the reply. Local DMs wait on that
# receipt (_wait_live_dm); so does this relay, on the same budget, so the sender gets the
# target's answer rather than a receipt when its Bot Chat happens to be open.
from tools.bot_live_delivery import await_delivery, deliver_to_live_owner, find_canonical_live_owner
from tools.bot_mode_dm import _LIVE_WAIT_SECONDS
owner_home = live_home if live_home is not None else Path(_hermes_home)
owner = find_canonical_live_owner(owner_home)
if owner is not None:
record = deliver_to_live_owner(owner_home, owner, message, author=author)
record = await_delivery(owner_home, record["delivery_id"], _LIVE_WAIT_SECONDS) or record
if record["status"] == "settled":
from tui_gateway.prompt_turn import _bot_mode_delivery_text
return _ok(rid, {"reply": _bot_mode_delivery_text((record.get("reply") or "").strip(), successful=True)})
if record["status"] in ("queued", "claimed"):
# Admitted but not answered within the budget: the receipt stays, the turn still runs.
reply = (f"Queued for @{resolved}'s open Bot Chat; it runs as that chat's next turn and the reply "
"will appear there. Do not resend.")
return _ok(rid, {"reply": reply})
from tools.bot_failure_reasons import CANCELLED, classify_agent_error
error = str(record.get("error") or f"Bot Chat delivery {record['status']}")
reason = record.get("reason") or (CANCELLED if record["status"] == "cancelled" else classify_agent_error(error))
return _err(rid, 5092, f"delivery turn failed: {error[-500:]}", data={"reason": reason})
if live_sid:
# A live Bot Chat here that advertises no mailbox: land the DM through prompt.submit, the
# composer's choke point, so role alternation, persistence and streaming behave as a
# typed message would (#100523). queued=True: a teammate's DM runs as the NEXT turn and
# never interrupts or steers a turn in flight (the default busy mode does).
submit_params: dict = {"session_id": live_sid, "text": message, "queued": True}
if author:
submit_params["_turn_author"] = DeliveryAuthor(author)
submitted = _methods["prompt.submit"](rid, submit_params)
if "error" in submitted:
return submitted
reply = f"Delivered into @{resolved}'s open Bot Chat; the reply will appear there."
return _ok(rid, {"reply": reply})
def _detail(p) -> str:
from tools.bot_failure_reasons import turn_failure_text
return turn_failure_text(p.stdout, p.stderr)
turn_env = delivery_env(author, live_home)
fd, tmp = tempfile.mkstemp(prefix="hermes-relay-dm-", suffix=".txt", text=True)
try:
with os.fdopen(fd, "w", encoding="utf-8") as f:
f.write(message)
# Per-profile turn lock serializes with any other delivery turn into this profile and
# covers only the turn window. Worst-case hold is lock wait (bot_mode.turn_wait_seconds,
# default 120s) + the 600s turn timeout, doubled on one retry — callers tolerate ~1320s.
# Worst-case handler hold is lock wait (bot_mode.turn_wait_seconds, default 120s) + the 600s
# turn timeout below — doubled when the retry policy grants one bounded re-run — so clients
# calling bot_relay.deliver must tolerate ~1320s before assuming failure. See #93091.
with acquire_turn_lock(root, resolved):
proc = _run(resolved, tmp, turn_env)
if proc.returncode != 0:
# Retry policy: transient classes re-run the SAME session once; context_overflow
# too — the retried turn's pre-API compaction pass compacts the over-threshold
# transcript first (no fresh session is minted). Auth/quota/config never retry.
# See #93091.
from tools.bot_failure_reasons import (
RETRY_NONE, classify_agent_error, retry_action)
if retry_action(classify_agent_error(_detail(proc))) != RETRY_NONE:
# The failed attempt already persisted the DM; the re-run resumes that row.
from tools.bot_relay import retry_turn_env
proc = _run(resolved, tmp, retry_turn_env(turn_env))
finally:
with contextlib.suppress(OSError):
os.unlink(tmp)
if proc.returncode != 0:
from tools.bot_failure_reasons import classify_agent_error
detail = _detail(proc)
return _err(rid, 5092, f"delivery turn failed: {detail[-500:] or proc.returncode}",
data={"reason": classify_agent_error(detail)})
# Use the same canonical whole-response predicate as live Bot Chat
# completion. A marker remains a successful turn, but is never sent
# back to the relay caller as visible prose.
from tui_gateway.prompt_turn import _bot_mode_delivery_text
reply = _bot_mode_delivery_text((proc.stdout or "").strip(), successful=True)
return _ok(rid, {"reply": reply})
except subprocess.TimeoutExpired:
# Every classified refusal has to ride `data.reason`: the Desktop forwards only that field,
# and the sender re-classifies from free text, which cannot name these. This branch is also
# `delivery_timeout`'s only producer.
from tools.bot_failure_reasons import DELIVERY_TIMEOUT
return _err(rid, 5093, "delivery turn timed out", data={"reason": DELIVERY_TIMEOUT})
except Exception as e:
reason = _failure_reason(e)
return _err(rid, 5096 if reason == "target_busy" else 5094, str(e), data={"reason": reason})
@method("bot_relay.reply")
def _(rid, params: dict, _root=_relay_root) -> dict:
"""Write a relayed ``reply`` and/or ``error`` (+ optional typed ``reason``, see
``tools.bot_failure_reasons``) for envelope ``id`` so the sender-side waiter picks it up."""
envelope_id = str(params.get("id") or "").strip()
if not envelope_id:
return _err(rid, 4093, "id required")
try:
from tools.bot_relay import write_reply
write_reply(_root(), envelope_id, reply=str(params.get("reply") or ""),
error=str(params.get("error") or ""), reason=str(params.get("reason") or ""))
return _ok(rid, {"ok": True})
except ValueError as e:
return _err(rid, 4094, str(e))
except Exception as e:
return _err(rid, 5095, str(e))
def register(server) -> None:
_registry.install(server)
from . import methods_groups
server._LONG_HANDLERS = server._LONG_HANDLERS | methods_groups.LONG_HANDLERS
for name in (
"get_hosted_room_service", "_WORKER_UNAVAILABLE", "_profile_name", "_requested_profile",
"_api_server_key", "_room_link_run_storage_durable"):
setattr(server, name, getattr(methods_groups, name))
methods_groups.bind_server(server)
methods_groups.register(server)